NBC San Diego /

News

Toxic Toy Law Threatens Local Businesses New law requires expensive testing for lead

By  RACHEL BIANCO

Updated 5:45 PM PDT, Tue, Jan 6, 2009

Related Topics: Laura Gulij

15 Comments   Post a comment Post a Comment

 

Meredith Shiflett is a new mom on a budget. She enjoys shopping for bargains at second hand stores like Baby Go Round in Mission Valley.

Toxic Toy Law Threatens Businesses

Watch Video

The cost of testing toys under a new law could be the end for some local businesses.

"My husband is in the military so we have a pretty limited budget, so it's pretty awesome 'cause even at Wal Mart clothes are like $10 more," said Shiflett.

Next month many of those bargains will be gone. 

"All of this, all of these small toys, the bigger toys, the equipment, all the clothing for the children, probably a lot of the books, about two thirds of my store, " said Laura Gulij, Baby Go Round's owner.

The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, passed by Congress in August, goes into effect February 10.  Among other things, it  mandates all childrens' products, toys, clothes, books, etc. are tested for toxic lead and phthalates, chemicals used in plastic.  Store owners must present a certificate proving the products were tested.

Many small business owners say they can't afford the testing and will have no choice but to get rid of much of their inventory.

"The cost of digestive testing for lead ranges from $130 to $180 per test on a shirt I am selling for $4.95," said Gulij.

The law is in response to several toy recalls in 2007. It was discovered large toy makers were selling products with dangerously high levels of lead content or chemicals that make children sick. Most of the toys were made in China.

Gulij and others are petitioning Congress to make changes to the law or to make small businesses exempt.

"I hope there's some modification, maybe it won't be retroactive, maybe it will be everything made from February 10th forward, " said Gulij.

The law also prohibits selling old baby products on line or at a yard sale, without a certificate proving the item has been determined to be lead-free.

Comments (15)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • NathanM Sunday, Jan 11 at 9:15 AM FLAG COMMENT Goodwill, Salvation Army, and consignment stores will be able to remain in business relatively unaffected (though they'll be expected to pay closer attention to product alerts and recalls). See this notice from the CPSC: http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prhtml09/09086.html
  • IV consumer Friday, Jan 9 at 1:06 PM FLAG COMMENT Voiceofreason, Unpainted wooden blocks and 100% undyed cotton clothes do not contain lead or phthalates, yet these have to be tested. Is it not China's imports that have been the main problem? What about a Mom that sits at home and makes stuffed animals to sell that are made with all 100% natural materials? Why does everyone have to suffer for the complete lack of due diligence that our lawmakers seem to ignore? "C ... MORE >
  • Anonymous Thursday, Jan 8 at 5:15 AM FLAG COMMENT Say good bye to Goodwill and the Salvation Army.
  • Anonymous Thursday, Jan 8 at 5:09 AM FLAG COMMENT This is a frivilous kneejerk law that's going to cost billions of unecessary testing. It might be a slight burden for megacorporations, but for the thousands of small business owners and second-hand stores, this will likely put them out of business. Want to donate clothes and toys, or sell something on ebay? Sorry, can't accept them without a passing certificate. And for what? You probably can't find one documented case of a c ... MORE >
  • Store Owner Wednesday, Jan 7 at 1:37 PM FLAG COMMENT I’m afraid your previous 2 comments perfectly reflect the climate of misunderstanding and confusion surrounding this bill. Nobody is asking for ‘permission to sell tainted and unsafe’ children’s products, and the law has nothing to do with “lead paint”. Its implications will be that any product made before February 10, 2009 will be deemed guilty until proven innocent (by $$$ lab testing). This would result in millions of tons ... MORE >

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?