Eric Fagan, Cathy Paternoster and Carl Fuerst

Authorities believe Eric Fagan (left) shot and killed Cathy Paternoster and wounded Carl Fuerst outside their Spring Valley Lake home in 1989.
Image 1 of 6 $image_credit
    • Eric-and-Cathy.jpg
    • Della-And-Cathy.jpg
    • carlcathykids1.jpg
    • Fuerst-on-gurney.jpg
    • Cathy.jpg
    • Eric-Fagan.jpg
Replay Slideshow

Eric Fagan, Cathy Paternoster and Carl Fuerst

Authorities believe Eric Fagan shot and killed Cathy Paternoster and wounded Carl Fuerst outside their Spring Valley Lake home in 1989. They say Fagan committed the murder to enable his girlfriend, Paternoster's mother, to get custody of the victim's daughter.

Please wait. Your gallery will be ready in 5 seconds.

Leave Comments
Don't Miss

local

27 minutes ago

Small Plane Down in Harbor

An aircraft went into the water near the Hilton Bayfront Hotel, according...

local

May 26, 2012

Banner Fire Scorches 4100 Acres

Crews from other parts of the state are traveling to San Diego County to help fight th...

as-seen-on

May 26, 2012

Wrongly Convicted Man Speaks Out

Brian Banks speaks to NBC 7 reporter Brandi Powell about being...

worth-the-drive

22 minutes ago

Marilyn Monroe in Palm Springs

The impressively sized artwork, complete with iconic blowing skirt, debuts in...