Eric Fagan, Cathy Paternoster and Carl Fuerst
Authorities believe Eric Fagan (left) shot and killed Cathy Paternoster and wounded Carl Fuerst outside their Spring Valley Lake home in 1989.
Eric Fagan, Cathy Paternoster and Carl Fuerst
Authorities believe Eric Fagan shot and killed Cathy Paternoster and wounded Carl Fuerst outside their Spring Valley Lake home in 1989. They say Fagan committed the murder to enable his girlfriend, Paternoster's mother, to get custody of the victim's daughter.
Please wait. Your gallery will be ready in 5 seconds.



Play Gallery







