Yearbook Reveals San Pasqual Language Teachers' 'Insensitive' Photos - NBC 7 San Diego

Yearbook Reveals San Pasqual Language Teachers' 'Insensitive' Photos

The school district said the photos were taken in the beginning of the year for use as teacher ID photos.

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Escondido Community Reflects Following Controversial Yearbook Photo

    Following a controversial yearbook photo, an Escondido school is reflecting on how some deemed it insensitive. NBC 7’s Melissa Adan has more. (Published Wednesday, May 22, 2019)

    Yearbooks released to seniors at San Pasqual High School in Escondido revealed what some employees were hiding in plain sight all year long.

    Some students and parents were outraged when they saw World Language Department faculty donning ponchos, sombreros and fake mustaches in their yearbook photos.

    The teachers' names featured the titles Señor and Señora while employee Millie Laurs, who was photographed wearing a black beret and black sunglasses, was addressed Madame.

    A statement released by the Escondido Union High School District said the photos were taken in the beginning of the year for use as teacher ID photos.

    World Language Faculty Accused of Cultural Insensitivity in Yearbook

    [DGO] World Language Faculty Accused of Cultural Insensitivity in Yearbook

    San Pasqual high school teachers are being accused of cultural insensitivity after controversial yearbook photos were released. NBC 7's Audra Stafford has more.

    (Published Wednesday, May 22, 2019)

    Two Hispanic parents who spoke with NBC 7 said they weren't offended by the photos, opting to reserve judgement until finding out the intention of teachers.

    “It doesn’t look offensive to me," parent Merced Juarez said. Olivia Olalde, fourth from the right in the list of pictures, was Juarez's son's Spanish teacher.

    “She’s a very good teacher. She was very strict with them because she wanted them to learn Spanish, to learn the language," Juarez said.

    Juarez said she recognized that the photos could have been an attempt by the teachers to celebrate Hispanic culture rather than shame it.

    Parent Martin Reyes Garcia wasn't offended either but saw how someone else might be.

    “It could be [offensive] because it’s not just for Mexican people, it’s for all the Latino people who speak Spanish and they could feel like they’re trying to make fun of us," he said.

    Yearbook Reveals San Pasqual Language Teachers' 'Insensitive' Photos

    [DGO] Yearbook Reveals San Pasqual Language Teachers' 'Insensitive' Photos

    NBC 7's Dave Summers spoke to two Hispanic parents who saw the photo and were not offended.

    (Published Tuesday, May 21, 2019)

    Parent and former San Pasqual High School student Tania Marin said didn’t find the pictures to be harmful.

    “I think that lately everything is so sensitive,” she told NBC 7. “If they were teaching Russian and they had a Russian hat, I would find it hilarious.”

    Brooke Angaga, a parent in the community, questioned who approved the photos in the first place.

    “As leaders in the school, that wasn't thought through very well. I'm sure it went through a lot of hands,” Angaga said.

    “San Pasqual High School takes pride in its rich history and diversity," SPHS Principal Casas, said in the statement. "It is our intent to use this situation as a tool to remind students, as well as staff, to remember the impacts of their words and actions. We are committed to continuing our efforts to ensure all students, families and staff feel welcome and valued.”

    Casas, whose Twitter profile says he was born in Tijuana, Mexico, later tweeted that "Cultural appropriation is offensive, even if the intent is not to offend, and has no place in our school. We have a lot of work to do @EUHSD."

    No other information was available.

    Please refresh this page for updates on this story. Details may change as more information becomes available.

    Get the latest from NBC 7 San Diego anywhere, anytime

    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android