Trump Cut Taxes for the Rich. Biden Wants to Raise Them

Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump were far apart on many issues — tax policy among them

Kevin Dietsch/UPI/Bloomberg via Getty Images

What to Know

  • President Joe Biden's tax plan would raise taxes for the wealthiest Americans, especially those making more than $400,000 a year.
  • Former President Donald Trump's signature tax law, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, cut taxes for most Americans. Its benefits went mostly to the rich.
  • Biden's agenda faces headwinds in a divided Senate. Democrats may be able to use a budget rule to pass a bill with a mere 50 votes.

Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump were far apart on many issues — tax policy among them.

The Biden administration is seeking to dismantle or reverse many aspects of his predecessor's signature tax law. The law cut taxes for businesses and a broad swath of Americans, with benefits accruing mostly to the wealthy.

Biden wants to raise taxes on the well-to-do, specifically those who make more than $400,000 a year. He would subject more of their earnings to Social Security taxes, repeal cuts to top income-tax rates, reduce the value of tax deductions and increase taxes on inherited wealth and capital gains.

More from Personal Finance:
Here's how Biden would avert a looming jobless benefits cliff
The Fed won't keep interest rates near zero forever — here's what to do now
51 million Americans increased their credit card debt because of Covid

The president also campaigned on a promise not to raise taxes on middle and low earners. Some policies, like expanded tax credits, would likely reduce their taxes.

In aggregate, the Biden administration aims to make the tax system more progressive, said Richard Winchester, a tax law professor at Seton Hall University.

"The richest people in America now pay a smaller portion in tax than the poorest people," he said.

Of course, it's unclear whether Biden can push his tax agenda through a divided Senate.

It appears Senate Democrats can pass most of the measures with a simple majority (rather than the typical 60-vote threshold) using a special budget rule, according to tax experts. Republicans used the same tool to pass the 2017 tax law.

"It frees up the Dems to enact legislation with the thinnest of majorities," said Steve Rosenthal, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.

Trump tax law

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act cut taxes in many ways.

The corporate tax rate fell to 21% from 35%, perhaps the law's signature feature.

But it also cut income taxes for many. The top tax rate, for example, fell to 37% from 39.6%. (It kicks in for income above $524,000 this year.) The law doubled the standard deduction and gave a 20% tax deduction to some business owners, like sole proprietors and partnerships. It exposed fewer families to estate taxes.

The law did limit some deductions for wealthy taxpayers, like one for state and local taxes. The tax break, previously unlimited, is now capped at $10,000 and doesn't rise with inflation.

In aggregate, the tax law put more money in Americans' pockets across the board, said Garrett Watson, a senior policy analyst at the Tax Foundation.

After-tax income rose 2.3% for the average person in 2018, the Tax Foundation estimated. The bottom fifth of earners saw a 0.8% increase, while the top 1% got a 3.8% boost, according to the projections.

It's projected to increase the federal budget deficit by just shy of $2 trillion over a decade.

Many of the cuts for individuals were temporary, however. They're scheduled to end after 2025, thereby raising tax rates.

Biden tax plan

Biden's plan would have the opposite effect. Taxes would rise for the richest and fall most for the poorest.

On average, the top 1% would pay $260,000 more in taxes next year, according to an Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center analysis. That represents almost 16% of their after-tax income.

Middle earners would get a $680 tax cut — 1.1% of their after-tax income. The lowest earners, making less than $25,000, would get a $760 cut — or 5.2% of their income.

"Our tax system cannot be tilted toward corporate interests and the wealthy, while those that are sustained predominately by wages bear an unequal burden," Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said last week in Senate testimony. "Biden will require corporations and the wealthiest Americans to pay their fair share."

Biden would target tax increases at those making more than $400,000 a year. His plan would raise about $2.1 trillion over a decade, according to the Tax Policy Center.

For one, he'd repeal the Trump tax cuts for that income group. (Their top tax rate, for example, would revert to 39.6% from 37%.)

He'd expose wages above $400,000 to Social Security payroll taxes. (Individuals currently pay a 6.2% tax on up to $142,800 of income.) This measure would raise $740 billion, the most among Biden's tax-agenda items, according to the Tax Policy Center.

People making less than the cap "are subject to tax on every dollar they earn at a flat tax rate," Winchester said. "Folks earning above that amount, it's tax-free money."

The Biden administration would also limit the value of itemized deductions for wealthy taxpayers to 28%.

Consider two taxpayers with $100 in tax deductions. Currently, a person in the 25% tax bracket can claim a deduction worth $25, whereas one in the 37% bracket can claim a larger tax break, $37. Biden's law would instead cap the wealthy person's break at $28 for every $100 of deductions.

Biden would also raise taxes on capital gains for taxpayers with incomes above $1 million. Wealthy taxpayers who sell stocks and bonds would pay a 39.6% top rate on any gains, compared with the current 20%.  

He'd raise the estate tax to 45% and apply it to more estates. In addition, he'd rescind the so-called "step up in basis," taxing a a stock's appreciation when its owner dies instead of allowing heirs to inherit unsold stock at its current fair market value.

He'd raise the corporate tax rate to 28% from 21%, and phase out the 20% pass-through deduction for wealthy business owners.

Meanwhile, the administration would temporarily expand the child tax credit and make it fully refundable, with benefits accruing most to those at the bottom of the income curve. The measure would reduce federal revenue by $240 billion over a decade, the largest outlay in Biden's plan, according to the Tax Policy Center.

First-time homebuyers would also get a refundable tax credit. The child and dependent care credit would be expanded and fully refundable.

Copyright CNBC
Contact Us