Pension Reform Initiative Overcomes Second Lawsuit

Judge Steven Denton ruled that the initiative won't affect the "structure" of city government

View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    Boxes of signatures in support of pension reform stacked at the San Diego City Clerk's office on Sept. 30, 2011.

    A second legal challenge to San Diego's "Comprehensive Pension Reform" initiative was rejected today by yet another Superior Court judge.

    The lawsuit, filed by mayoral candidate and attorney Hud Collins, claims the measure is a major revision to the City Charter, and can't be put on the June ballot by way of petition signatures.

    Second Case Against Pension Measure Fails

    [DGO] Second Case Against Pension Measure Fails
    A lawsuit filed by lesser-known mayoral candidate Hud Collins was denied Wednesday, Mark Mullen reports. Collins' provision claimed that the Comprehensive Pension Reform initiative required more formality, discussion and deliberation than the iniative process would have allowed. (Published Wednesday, Feb 22, 2012)

    But Judge Steven Denton ruled that the initiative won't affect the "structure" of city government, so it's a valid amendment to the charter.

    On Tuesday, Judge William Dato dismissed a challenge by state labor regulators to disqualify the measure on grounds that city officials violated labor laws in crafting and promoting it.

    Bid to Halt SD Pension Measure Fails

    [DGO] Bid to Halt SD Pension Measure Fails
    Councilmember Carl DeMaio and San Diego City Attorney Jan Goldsmith react to the recent courtroom challenge that will allow residents to vote for pension reform. Gene Cubbison reports (Published Tuesday, Feb 21, 2012)

    “Two legal wins in the span of one week demonstrate the legal rigor of the pension reform initiative,” said mayoral candidate and Councilmember Carl DeMaio in a statement.  

    Tell us what you think. Comment below, fan us on Facebook, mention us on Twitter @nbcsandiego, or download our improved iPhone app.