NBC San Diego /

News

No Posthumous Medal of Honor for Local Marine

Updated 8:26 AM PDT, Thu, Nov 20, 2008

The Department of Defense has rejected a request to award the Medal of Honor to a San Diego Marine who witnesses say threw himself on a grenade to save his colleagues in Iraq.

 

The Department of Defense has rejected a request to award the Medal of Honor to a San Diego Marine who witnesses say threw himself on a grenade to save his colleagues in Fallujah, Iraq in 2004.

Rep. Duncan Hunter, who along with other politicians appealed the decision to award Sgt. Rafael Peralta the Navy Cross instead, said Wednesday he was disappointed.

Peralta's nomination was tainted by reports he was accidentally shot by a fellow Marine shortly before an insurgent lobbed the grenade. Eyewitnesses described how the Marine deliberately used his body to protect fellow troops from a grenade blast.

But Secretary of Defense Robert Gates says five independent experts reviewed the evidence and found it did not meet the required standard.

Peralta was assigned to the 3rd Marine Expeditionary Force in Hawaii. Originally from Mexico, Peralta signed up for the Marines as soon as he received legal residency. 

Read more about this story in the San Diego Union-Tribune.

Comments (11)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • Wonkatania Thursday, Nov 20 at 8:50 AM FLAG COMMENT This is akin to kicking him while he is down. First he gets shot by a fellow Marine, he then jumps on a grenade to save the guy who shot him, grenade goes off, he dies, and the Department of Defense casts a doubt on his heroism because a fellow Marine shot him to begin with? What a joke. What difference does it make that he was shot first? I am sure that when he jumped on the grenade he did not do it because he thought was ... MORE >
  • unbelievable Thursday, Nov 20 at 7:47 AM FLAG COMMENT what a joke everyone of our men and women fighting deserve more respect than this!!!!!!!!
  • David Thursday, Nov 20 at 4:14 AM FLAG COMMENT It was mentioned on a previous article that the dissaproval was in lieu of injuries already sustained by friendly fire, as if to say "well, you are dead anyways". Is it right to say that a wounded Soldier does not merit honors warranted to previous soldiers before him for similar acts on the basis of physical state?
  • Tom Thursday, Nov 20 at 3:30 AM FLAG COMMENT if he was injured by friendly fire and fell on a grenade then their is no act of heroism. Seems like the DOD gave him the benefit of the doubt by given him the Navy Cross. Regardless, he died in the line of duty serving his country and desrves honor and respect and I am sure his family cares...However, his mom making this a racial issue does not do justice to a fine Marine.
  • bluidi Wednesday, Nov 19 at 11:14 PM FLAG COMMENT Please, give me a break, either he did it or he didn't what other facts are there?

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?